Friday, October 19, 2018

Joblessness or Less Jobs? Dissecting Unemployment Crisis


                    
India has a favourable demographic advantage over other countries of the world as it has half of its population below the age of 25 and more than 65% below the age of 35. By 2020, the average age of an Indian will be 29 years which is lesser than China and Japan. With the potential for exponential growth and the surplus working population, the only Achilles heel for development of our country is the alarming growth of unemployment. The pressing issue needs immediate attention and solution to achieve  the anticipated GDP in a sustainable way.

The fundamental step in finding solution to any public good issue is to know the state of affairs through the statistics collected. In this regard, Government surveys to monitor and record jobs vacancies and unemployment rate are not proactive enough to say the least. There isn't enough political will to create the right survey design and infrastructure that records the data on a monthly or at least quarterly basis in stead of the existing system of once in five or ten years.
Having said that, the World Bank dispels the wrong notion of growth without jobs (Jobless Growth). According to it's recent report, 1% growth in GDP should ideally create 7.5 lakh jobs in the economy. At this rate India must create at least 5.25 million jobs with its 7% GDP. This implies that there could be instances of low demand for jobs but never a standstill.The low points could be due to various disruptions like Demonitization, Implementation of GST or Global Financial Crisis and the like.
Having understood that there is always a demand for jobs, the next question is how much demand?
Factors affecting the intensity of demands and vacancies are
Firstly, large scale substitution of labour with Capital and Automation which decreases Employment Elasticity rate. Employment Elasticity is the growth in job demands per 1% increase in GDP. In 2018, the figure is 0.2% jobs creation for 1% GDP growth.
Secondly, economy's declining ability to create jobs. This trend is observed not just in India but globally.
To counter the two factors, government must focus on generating jobs rather than increasing GDP.

Why create work than improve GDP?

Assuming that every one percent increase in GDP creates 6 lakh jobs (realistic assumption aganist the projected 7.5 lakh which gives 4.2 million for 7% GDP), every year at least 50% of 15 million(7.5 million) of the 15+ age group people seek employment rather than higher education or marriage. This creates a jobs gap of 3.3 million. In addition to women who may opt to work, the jobs gap could be as much as 9 million(60% of working age). 

Where to employ the excess?

Agricultural sector in India is inundated with surplus rural labourers who are migrating to urban areas in search of work. Growth in urban areas is in itself under threat because of changing demography and trade wars. It is estimated by various international organizations that growth in global working age population would face a 1% dip in growth which translates to 1.5% in India.With all these challenges ahead, policy makers must proactively design reforms to employ people.

World is flooded with capital so money is fuelled in large investments of automation and technology. Technology has the tendency to create polarized jobs. It creates humongous demand in very high end skills like Artificial Intelligence, Cyber Security, Machine learning experts and low end skills like drivers and delivery boys. Middle skilled labourers like Bank staff and Java coders go out of work because of technology upgradation and business consolidation. Blue collar jobs like logistics, warehousing, education, tourism and healthcare are booming. Data science and machine learning jobs await for thousands of upskilled employees in commerce, banking and energy sectors.

How to employ?

There is a call for change in skill development and planning. The need of the hour is to improve and reform the Labour market information systems.Identifying 
the skills that are required and provide training on that. Decentralize planning and bring it under the ambit of state and local governments. Once when the Labour market laws are reformed, the government and industries must ensure reasonable salary and security benefits and provide subsidies if needed. 
When the required skills are identified and provided and a secured salary ensure, the next step is to guarantee enough jobs and vacancies. Three ways that can happen are :
1.Medium scale units which have higher scope of employment must be encouraged through respective labour law reforms and easier access to credit by the government.
2.To aim for smart urbanization by providing  good infrastructure and good governance.
3. Optimization of government funds and focus on public good than providing freebies.

Need for Change

In accordance with the first two suggestions on the reform of skill development, government's decision to merge NCVT (National Council for Vocational Training) and NSDA (National Skill Development Agency) into NCVET (National Council for Vocational and Educational Training) is a welcoming change.
NCVET combines the legislative and executive function of Skill Development.It would Establish minimum standards, approve, regulate, assess, monitor and govern all aspects of skill development planning and training. As for Labour reforms, government must focus on jobs generating growth than merely growth. As mentioned earlier, there is no bigger myth than jobless growth. Jobs growth can never be consistent and the better we understand this, the more appropriate will be our response.
Government must take into account the degenerative trend in global growth while formulating labour reforms and target ways to minimize job gaps which is around 3 to 4 million annually. The unemployment crisis rampant in rural to urban migrants due to saturation in agricultural sector must find a place in the reforms too. With this holistic approach, government can effectively tackle the problem of joblessness.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Statue of Unity - They are two different words

This huge piece of physical structure is a symbol of the competence of the current government. Sounds good right?  But that only covers on...